Mashed potatoes are a staple of thanksgiving, though this is how I make mashed potatoes all the time, especially since Josh loves mashed potatoes.
I’ve made mashed potatoes with a variety of potatoes, and I find yellow potatoes, Yukon Golds, and white potatoes to work the best. Russets are too starchy and need a lot of butter and salt to get any other flavor other than just starch. I like to make my cubes by quartering a medium potato to get thin strips of potatoes, then cutting them every half an inch. I have also added garlic to my potatoes before and really enjoyed that. I also like to add bit of parsley flakes on top after they come out of the oven/ on the plate. I also have added cheese before to the top of my potatoes before baking, and I prefer shredding white sharp cheddar cheese, but that’s just my favorite cheese, so you can choose what you like. This is a very forgiving recipe and there are many ways you can customize it to make it your own!
- Wash, peel, and cube about 4-5 lbs of potatoes.
- Place potatoes into a pot and rinse again 1-2 times, then fill pot with warm water and place over medium-high heat.
- Once the potatoes are boiling or the water starts to get starchy, it should take about 20 minutes. The potatoes are done when you can stab a large piece with a fork, and the potato splits and falls off the fork. If you want less chunky mashed potatoes cook for an additional 3 minutes.
- Strain your potatoes then put in a large bowl to beat with a hand mixer, or put in the bowl of a stand mixer with the paddle attachment.
- Start pulsing low speed and add 1/2 a cup of milk and 1 stick of butter (1/2 cup).
- Once most of the big chunks are broken up, turn your speed to medium-low and slowly add more milk until you reach your desired consistency. Add salt to taste. You can also add an optional tablespoon of garlic paste or 2 tablespoons of minced garlic, if you desire.
- Optional: Place your potatoes into a casserole dish, add desired toppings (shredded cheese, butter, chives, etc), and heat in oven covered or uncovered to keep warm. If you cook uncovered, the top will gain color and the potatoes will also begin to rise, becoming more airy and losing moisture making them almost cake like. If you cook them covered, you won’t gain color and you will also lose less moisture.
To see the other recipes I cooked this year, head back to my Thanksgiving: Overview post!














